Frnk you are sooooo bad
BMI is a nightmare, it never takes frame or bone structure into account
My BMI was almost bang on 30 when I started WW last year - I know I was pretty chunky, but obese?
Almost two stone down, I am still in the overweight category at just under 27 but I'm really not that big, fitting a 12/14 in clothes at 5ft 7 and 56 years old isn 't so awful surely?
My mate from the meetings, Violet, is the same height as me but with a much smaller frame - she started WW around the same time as me, but weighed less then than I do now!
Now she's almost down into the 9st something range, but still wants to lose a bit. BMI is too general.....
Apparently for health the best thing you can do is measure your height with a piece of string, then fold that into two and measure your waist. As long as it goes round you are unlikely to suffer health related problems - ie at a height of 67" like me, as long as my waist is less than 33.5" I am ok. Mine is less
I'm still keeping going though