You aren't alone MM.
We often serve squirrel as a starter if we are having friends for dinner (you'd need too many of them to serve as a main course) and I always, always ask people first if they want to try it. If they say no, I always ask if they would prefer it not to be on the menu at all or if they just want an alternative.
One or two friends have opted not to try it but have been happy for it to be served - I just do them something different (although very often they are curious and end up having a nibble anyway).
But, everyone who has tried it does like it - it is a very inoffensive meat.