Help!!! Which boots UPDATE

[miasmum]

both sitting in my bedroom, both too big, but ok with thick socks.
http://www.debenhams.com/webapp/wcs/sto ... high+boots
http://www.debenhams.com/webapp/wcs/sto ... adtype=pla

[Diflower]

Hmm, they are similar aren't they.
It must come down to which are the most comfortable and versatile. Have you tried them on with different things, jeans/leggings/skirt, whatever?
It looks as if the Faith ones have a thicker sole, which would keep your feet warmer, as well as being more hard-wearing, so for me that might be the deciding factor

[Kaz]

Agreeing with Di that the Faith ones have a thicker sole so would probably be more hardwearing - also the tan colour will be more versatile. Tan boots go with anything!

[debih]

I like them both!

[Rodo]

The Faith boots have 3 poor reviews - funny noise when walking, cheap stitching, cheap feel to leather.

However the others haven't any reviews as yet. I think I like them better than the Faith ones just by appearance.

[Kaz]

Me too, they are both lovely, but if I couldn't have both choc and tan I would always go for the tan for the versatility

[Kaz]

hmmm yes that's true Rodo, but they do have 4 out of 5 stars overall from 14 reviews I'd probably want to see and touch them to decide about the quality............it's difficult online.

[Kaz]

The thing with these online reviews is that they are so subjective! After I bought my boots in town and posted a link to them on the old VV, I read the online reviews out of curiosity. Most were good, but some were very scathing - and yet I love my boots!

[miasmum]

People tend to review if they love or hate, generally the latter. The Faith ones do feel cheap, and they look almost second hand, but then they are meant to be distressed.

[Ally]

I love the black ones Shell.